This month’s book club pick is Rachel Cohn and David Levithan‘s 2006 novel Nick & Norah’s Infinite Playlist. A film adaptation was released in 2008 directed by Peter Sollett.
The film follows a group of teenagers over 24 hours in New York City.
We first meet Nick O’Leary portrayed by Michael Cera (Juno, Superbad, Scott Pilgrim vs. the World) in his Hoboken, New Jersey bedroom. Nick still clad in his sleepwear is leaving an awkward post-break up message on his ex-girlfriend Tris’ phone.
Next we go to Sacred Heart, an all girls school, where Tris (Alexis Dziena) has one of Nick’ mix CDs entitled ‘The Road to Closure: Vol. 12’. After Tris dumps it in the bin Norah (Kat Dennings) is quick to retrieve it. She clearly has a connection to this mysterious musio Nick.
Back at Nick’s, his gay bandmates Thom (Aaron Yoo) and Dev (Rafi Gavron) have arrived to pick up mopey Nick for a gig that night. Nick is the bass player in an queercore punk band ‘The Jerk-Offs.’
At the gig Tris turns up with new beau Gary (Zachary Booth). After Tris mocks Norah for not having boyfriend Norah asks Nick, unaware who he is, to be her boyfriend for five minutes. This is different to the novel where it is Nick who asks Norah.
Norah’s best friend Caroline (Ari Graynor) is getting increasingly more drunk. Norah just wants to take Caroline home. Nick’s bandmates hoping that Norah can get Tris off his mind offer to take Caroline home, so Nick and Norah can spend the time getting to know each other better while searching for elusive indie band Where’s Fluffy’s secret show.
Unfortunately Thom, Dev and their new beefy friend (Richard B. Wright) lose Caroline. Nick and Norah must join the search for Caroline, and find out what they want from each other.
Part of the magic of the novel is the dual narrative – Cohn writing chapters from Norah’s perspective and Levithan from Nick’s. This magic is lost in translating the book to film.
Cera and Dennings have good chemistry together and thanks to witty dialogue the film is a little bit better than your average teen-rom com but overall it does not offer anything new or special.