Film & TV Reviews

FILM REVIEW: The Chocolate War


This month’s book club pick is Robert Cormier’s 1974 novel The Chocolate War. A film adaptation written and directed by Keith Gordon was released in 1988.

The film opens with fifteen-year-old freshman Jerry Renault (Ilan Mitchell-Smith*Weird Science) playing football while two students watch from the bleachers.

The two students are Archie (Wallace Langham) and Obie (Doug Hutchison). Both are members of The Vigils, a secret underground student society.

*Interesting fact Mitchell-Smith is now a Professor of Medieval Literature at California State University Long Beach.

Jerry (Ilan Mitchell-Smith)
Jerry (Ilan Mitchell-Smith)
Archie (Wallace Langham) and Obie (Doug Hutchison)
Archie (Wallace Langham) and Obie (Doug Hutchison)

Each student when joining the Vigils is assigned a task. Albie gives Jerry’s the assignment to refuse to sell any chocolates for ten days during the school’s fundraiser.

Jerry decides after the ten days to still refuse to sell chocolates, which puts him at heads with the Vigils and sadistic vice principal Brother Leon (John Glover). His defiant act turns into an all-out war with bullying and coercion.

Brother Leon (John Glover) and Gregory Bailey (Wayne Young)
Brother Leon (John Glover) and Gregory Bailey (Wayne Young)

The first two acts of the film remain reasonably faithful to the book. The ending of the film is changed to give the film a more optimistic ‘Hollywood’ style ending where good prevails over evil. The ending of the book is far bleaker.

First time director Keith Gordon was a teen actor himself (he made his film debut at 17 in Jaws 2) so he has a good understanding of a young actor’s process. He was also only 27 when he directed The Chocolate War. Other than are few issues, such as editing choices and the use of some fantasy sequences that don’t always work, it is a competent effort for a first time director and he largely delivers good performances from his cast.

By Graeme Cash

Film, television, theatre, popular media culture, ya fiction, travel...pretty much my life. Based in Bay of Plenty, New Zealand

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s